LATEST NEWS
February 11, 2008
What does “the owner is not obligated to accept the lowest or any bid” really mean?
How much discretion do you have in the selection of tenders? If you are using standard tender documents, less than you may think.
The privilege clause included in most tender documents states: “the owner is not obligated to accept the lowest or any bid”.
Some people think that this clause gives the owner or general contractor the ability to choose whichever bid he or she pleases. It doesn’t. The courts have found that this clause merely allows an owner the discretion to consider factors other than price alone in assessing the cost of respective bids.
That discretion allows an owner to take a more “nuanced” view of cost than the prices quoted in the tenders, but it does not allow an owner to award the contract to anyone.
An owner can only rely on a privilege clause if there are legitimate and objective business reasons that support the owner’s decision.
The basic privilege clause does not relieve an owner of his or her other obligations, and in particular its obligation to treat bidders fairly or to accept only materially compliant bids.
Because of the limited nature of the discretion afforded by that traditional privilege clause, owners have broadened the wording of their privilege clauses.
It is common now to find privilege clauses that give owners very broad discretion in the selection of the preferred bidder, including the discretion to consider materially noncompliant bids.
The importance of these types of privilege clauses cannot be overstated.
Fundamentally, tendering law is contract law and ordinary contract principles apply.
A bidder’s decision to participate in the procurement process is considered by the courts to constitute an acceptance of the terms of the tender as drafted by the owner no matter how onerous the conditions included in the tender may be. Accordingly, from a contractor’s perspective, where the preparation of a bid for a particular project is going to be costly and labour intensive, a contractor should carefully review the tender in order to understand any limitations on its ability to seek redress from an owner prior to making that investment of time and resources.
Conversely, from an owner’s perspective, there is little to lose by the inclusion of various privilege clauses within the tender’s terms and conditions.
Until such time as contractors concertedly refuse to participate in a tender process due to perceived unfairness in the terms and conditions, a careful owner or general contractor will include a number of privilege clauses in the tender in order to reasonably restrict liability.
Norm Streu and Chris Hirst are partners in the Construction & Engineering Group of the Vancouver law firm Alexander Holburn Beaudin & Lang LLP. Norm is a past chair of the Vancouver Regional Construction Association.
If you have any questions about this decision, or any construction law related issue, please feel free to call Norm or Chris at (604) 484-1700.
| MOST POPULAR STORIES |
- High-tech oil sands project near Fort McMurray, Alberta could change industry
- TransCanada begins construction on British Columbia-Alberta pipeline
- VIDEO: B.C. Construction Association welcomes standardized contract forms
- Port Mann Bridge under construction
- Crane accident kills worker at construction site in Burnaby, British Columbia
- 20 Most Popular Stories
| TODAY’S TOP CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS |
These projects have been selected from 263 projects with a total value of $8,919,878,049 that Reed Construction Data Building Reports reported on yesterday.
NATURAL GAS PROCESSING FACILITY
$500,000,000 Fort Nelson BC Prebid
$250,000,000 Fort Nelson BC Negotiated
$35,000,000 Winnipeg MB Prebid
| CURRENT STORIES |
- Crane operator certification deadline looms in British Columbia
- High-tech oil sands project near Fort McMurray, Alberta could change industry
- Saskatoon bridge closed indefinitely over structural concerns
- City of Regina project turns up all sorts of surprises
- Awareness about qualifications-based selection lacking: Survey
- Canadian Institute of Steel Construction launches Steel Day
- Saskatchewan bridge collapses, causing crane to topple
- Crane tips over, killing worker and injuring two
- Saskatoon man pulled from hole at construction site
- Churchill airport gets government cash for infrastructure upgrades
- Stantec acquires health care architectural firm
- Ground broken on Halifax RCMP headquarters
- Fanshawe College’s new Centre for Applied Transportation Technologies goes green
- Vanbots continues work on York University Life Sciences Building in Toronto
- Manitoba introduces new farm building code
- Heavy rains wash away bridges to Nova Scotia fishing village
- South Korea calls for financial safety net
- Jobsite safety a shared duty: Mechanical Contractors Association
- New technology could help find Jimmy Hoffa: Study
| ALEX’S ECONOMICS BLOG |

Reed Construction Data Chief Economist Alex Carrick discusses current developments in the North American economic environment with emphasis on the construction industry.
- Canada’s construction starts in a transition phase (August 27, 2010)
- U.S. initial jobless claims rise to half a million again (August 19, 2010)
- It’s been 35 years since institutional construction starts as strong (August 6, 2010)
- More

















