JOC ARCHIVES

LATEST NEWS  Engineering

November 4, 2009

Infrastructure spending

Local governments may be overpaying for construction procurement, study says

Realistic and better structured construction contract procurement practices could save governments province-wide $1 billion, an industry study concludes.

“There is a lot of infrastructure money being spent and as an industry we want to make sure that money goes as far as possible,” explains Andy Manahan, executive director of the Residential and Civil Construction Alliance of Ontario (RCCAO).

'Towards A Fair and Balanced Approach: A Commentary on Government Procurement of Construction in the GTHA,' a study commissioned by the RCCAO, was authored by Stephen Bauld, president of Purchasing Consultants International Inc., one of Canada’s leading experts in the public procurement field.

“While the study conservatively estimates that taxpayers are paying at least five per cent more than they should because of these practices, that’s very much on the low side,” says Bauld in a statement. “At the upper end, it could be as much as 20 per cent.”

In the Greater Toronto-Hamilton Area, approximately $2.6 billion is spent annually on construction by federal, provincial and municipal governments, their respective boards and agencies, as well as by school boards, universities, community colleges and hospitals, the study states.

All GTHA governments alone may be paying an additional $500 million a year more than is necessary for construction projects.

“There is a lot of reference in the report to the transferring of risk and that has a lot of ramifications,” says Manahan. “We want to look at whole bunch of different areas where government is working with the best intentions with taxpayer dollars but is inadvertently resulting in higher prices for construction products.”

Government purchasing policies and contract documents are at the root of the problem, Bauld confirms. They have become “so onerous” in the transfer of the risk to construction contractors that many qualified companies simply do not bid.

This purchasing and contract landscape creates a less competitive marketplace for public sector work.

Savings that could be found in this area could be used to fund additional needed infrastructure work or reduce looming deficits, notes the study.

Print | Email | Comment

MOST POPULAR STORIES
TODAY’S TOP CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS

These projects have been selected from 263 projects with a total value of $8,919,878,049 that Reed Construction Data Building Reports reported on yesterday.

NATURAL GAS PROCESSING FACILITY

$500,000,000 Fort Nelson BC Prebid

NATURAL GAS PLANT

$250,000,000 Fort Nelson BC Negotiated

HOSPITAL ADDN

$35,000,000 Winnipeg MB Prebid

Daily Top 10

ALEX’S ECONOMICS BLOG

Reed Construction Data Chief Economist Alex Carrick discusses current developments in the North American economic environment with emphasis on the construction industry.

TODAY’S TOP JOBS

Project Manager - Electrical Construction
Ontario-Richmond Hill

Traffic Manager / Dispatcher
Ontario-Mississauga

PROJECT MANAGERS & SUPERINTENDENTS
Ontario-Toronto

Surveyor/Layout Person
Ontario-Toronto

Senior Project Manager/Estimator
British Columbia-Delta

Chief/Senior Estimator
Ontario-Brampton

Senior Estimator
British Columbia-Vancouver

Contracts Manager
Ontario-Mississauga

Heavy Duty Equipment Mechanic
Manitoba-Flin Flon

Heavy Duty Equipment Mechanic
Manitoba-Thompson

More jobs 

myJobsite.ca

Your gateway to
the top careers
in construction
and design